================================================================================
MIXED CLAUDE 3 — QA REPORT
SET LIST 4 — TITLE UNRESOLVED [SEE SECTION 4]
MIXED_CLAUDE_3_QA_REPORT_SET_LIST_4_VOL1.txt
================================================================================
Generated: May 9, 2026
Role: Mixed Claude 3 — QA Verifier replacing Black Claude 1 on weekly cooldown
Sources cross-referenced:
  Quick guide instance 1:    line 2750      → Title: "Downward Spiral"
  Quick guide instance 2:    line 35741     → Title: "Downward Spiral"
  Full text track listing:   line 17029     → Section header: "PARTNERED TO THE CRIME"
  Track listing index:        line 37993     → Header: "PARTNERED TO THE CRIME"
  Rolling Stone review:       line 32564     → Header: "PARTNER TO THE CRIME"
  One-sentence summary:       line 33180     → Label: "Partner to the Crime"
================================================================================

1. VERIFIED ELEMENTS
--------------------
Collection identity: SET LIST 4 (number confirmed across all sources) ✅

AIO Page Name (format locked — title pending Tom decision):
  SET LIST 4 — [TITLE PENDING TOM CONFIRMATION] — ALL-IN-ONE

Track Count: 12 tracks ✅

Track Order — all source forms agree:
  1.  Married To Something Else
  2.  Watering the Weeds
  3.  Rest In Peace
  4.  Downward Spiral  [SEE SECTION 4 — TRACK-BLEED RISK]
  5.  Rat Park
  6.  Rehab
  7.  Something In My Genes
  8.  Alcohol
  9.  Empty Bottle
  10. My Best Friends
  11. Old Friends
  12. Let Me Live the Dream

GX Total: Calculated 24, Source states 24 — CLEAN ✅
  All 12 tracks rated PG-13 (12 × 2 = 24) ✅

Lead Rating: PG-13 ✅
Trigger Warning: Present — EXTREME TRIGGER WARNING confirmed ✅
  (Full text header: "EXTREME TRIGGER WARNING — SET LIST FOUR")
Rolling Stone Review: Present — confirmed ✅
Strategic Arc: "Addiction, domestic abuse, death. Dark but artistic." ✅
Artist Comparison: Johnny Cash, Warren Zevon, Nine Inch Nails ✅
All four-word summaries: Confirmed consistent across both quick guide instances ✅

2. SUSPECT ELEMENTS
-------------------
SUSPECT 4-1 — CROSS-COLLECTION TRACK CHECK — "REHAB"
  "Rehab" appears in both Tom Legacy and Tom Personal category indexes.
  Confirmed as Track 6 of Set List 4. Cross-reference artist comparison
  section (line 32095) explicitly names "Rehab" as a Set List 4 track. ✅
  No duplicate collection issue detected.

SUSPECT 4-2 — "OLD FRIENDS" TITLE CHECK
  Track 11: "Old Friends" — confirmed in all source locations. ✅
  Distinct from any other catalog track. No cross-collection risk.

SUSPECT 4-3 — ROLLING STONE REVIEW PARTIAL TRACK COVERAGE
  Tracks mentioned: Married to Something Else (T1), Watering the Weeds (T2),
    Rest In Peace (T3), Rat Park (T5), Rehab (T6), Alcohol (T8),
    Empty Bottle (T9), Let Me Live the Dream (T12)
  Tracks NOT mentioned: Downward Spiral (T4), Something In My Genes (T7),
    My Best Friends (T10), Old Friends (T11)
  Coverage: 8 of 12 tracks.
  ⚠️ FLAG — Tom to confirm review completeness.

3. MISSING MATERIAL
-------------------
  No partial lyric notations detected for any Set List 4 track. ✅
  Standard Tom-supply items: Blocks 1, 3, 5, 13.
  AIO PAGE NAME: Cannot be finalized until Tom resolves title conflict.

4. TITLE CONFLICTS — CRITICAL — BLOCKER
----------------------------------------
ENTRY: SET LIST 4 TITLE — THREE COMPETING FORMS — ALL IN SOURCE

  Form 1: "Downward Spiral"
    Source locations: Quick guide instance 1 (line 2750), Quick guide
      instance 2 (line 35741), full text body references
    Context: Used as the SET TITLE in the two most recently generated
      quick guide pages.
    RISK: "Downward Spiral" is ALSO Track 4's title within this same set.
      If the set is named "Downward Spiral," the collection and its own
      Track 4 share the same name — creating a track-bleed ambiguity.
      Black Claude 1 documented this as the confirmed active instance of
      the track-bleed contamination pattern.

  Form 2: "Partner to the Crime"
    Source locations: Rolling Stone review header (line 32564),
      one-sentence summary section (line 33180)
    Context: Appears in the editorial and summary layers of the source.

  Form 3: "Partnered to the Crime"
    Source locations: Full text section header (line 17029),
      track listing index header (line 37993)
    Context: Used as the actual section titles in the main content body.

  FREQUENCY ANALYSIS:
    "Downward Spiral" as set title:  2 (quick guides)
    "Partner to the Crime":          2 (Rolling Stone + summary section)
    "Partnered to the Crime":        2 (full text body + track index)
    All three forms have equal frequency. Cannot resolve by frequency.

  AUTHORITY TIER ANALYSIS:
    Quick guide (Tier 1 structured data):   "Downward Spiral"
    Full text body (Tier 1 content):        "Partnered to the Crime"
    Rolling Stone (editorial):              "Partner to the Crime"
    Summary section (editorial):            "Partner to the Crime"
    CONFLICT: Two Tier 1 source types disagree.

  ADDITIONAL CONSIDERATION:
    The CONTENT > placement/order rule (Tom's canon rule) means the newest
    confirmed naming takes precedence. However, both "Downward Spiral"
    (quick guides) and "Partnered to the Crime" (full text body) are
    present in the same document version. Neither is demonstrably older.

  STATUS: [BLOCKED] — Tom must select the final canonical title.
  This is the single most important outstanding title decision in the
  entire 34-collection catalog. All three forms are documented and
  confirmed — no single form can be selected by QA alone.

  Tom's options:
    A. "Downward Spiral" — matches quick guide; risk of track-bleed with T4
    B. "Partner to the Crime" — editorial form; shorter
    C. "Partnered to the Crime" — full text body form; avoids track-bleed

5. CATEGORY CONFLICTS
---------------------
  No contamination detected in Set List 4's category data.
  Drugs and Alcohol category: "Rehab," "Alcohol," "Empty Bottle," "Rat Park"
  all appear there — thematically appropriate. ✅

6. GX / PROFANITY CONFLICTS
----------------------------
  GX CLEAN ✅. All 12 tracks PG-13 — no higher or lower ratings to verify.
  "EXTREME TRIGGER WARNING" header is unusual but confirmed in source. ✅
  No NC-17 or X-rated tracks.

7. CONTAMINATION WARNINGS
--------------------------
  TRACK-BLEED WARNING: If "Downward Spiral" is selected as the set title,
    the AIO page would have a collection named "Downward Spiral" containing
    Track 4 also named "Downward Spiral." Navigation, indexing, and search
    systems must handle this carefully. Tom should be aware of this risk
    when making the title decision.

8. RECOMMENDED FIXES
--------------------
  - Tom must select canonical title before any AIO generation begins.
  - If "Downward Spiral" is selected: add disambiguation note in Block 2
    or Block 4 to clarify collection vs. track name.
  - No GX fixes needed.
  - Tom to confirm Rolling Stone review completeness (8 of 12 tracks).

9. GENERATOR READINESS STATUS
------------------------------
[BLOCKED]
Title conflict unresolved. AIO page cannot be named or generated until
Tom selects from: "Downward Spiral" / "Partner to the Crime" /
"Partnered to the Crime."

All other elements of Set List 4 are verified and ready. GX is clean.
Track order is confirmed. As soon as Tom makes the title decision,
this collection upgrades to [READY WITH FLAGS] immediately.

================================================================================
END — MIXED_CLAUDE_3_QA_REPORT_SET_LIST_4_VOL1.txt
================================================================================
