================================================================================
BLACK_CLAUDE_1_QA_REPORT_SL22_INHERENT_ABSENCE_VOL1.txt
COLLABORHYTHM / COLLABTUNES ARCHIVE QA PIPELINE
================================================================================
Session: May 9, 2026
Role: Black Claude 1 — Verification / QA / Canon Stabilization
Source: 34_ALBUMS_BOOKS_1_and_2_back_to_back.pdf (903 pages)
Verification target: SET LIST 22 — INHERENT ABSENCE — ALL-IN-ONE (White Claude 2)
Authority hierarchy: Full-text (1) > Master index (2) > Quick-ref (3) > Editorial (4) > Category index (5)
================================================================================

PIPELINE FIRSTS / RECORDS IN SL22:
  — First NEGATIVE GX delta in pipeline (calc 54 > stated 52)
  — Largest set in catalog: 19 tracks (prior record: SL18 at 14)
  — First pure X lead rating (SL21 was compound NC-17/X)
  — First comparison table with NO named artists (genre descriptors only)
  — First Book 2 index title spelling variant: "MOCUMENTARY" vs "MOCKUMENTARY"
  — Thirteenth consecutive clean Rolling Stone editorial (SL9–SL22)

================================================================================
SECTION 1: TITLE VERIFICATION
================================================================================

STATUS: ✅ CONFIRMED — ZERO CONFLICTS — 7 STRUCTURAL APPEARANCES + PROSE REFS

Source appearances confirmed:
  Line 4010:  QR index 1 — "Set List 22 — Inherent Absence"
  Line 24326: Full-text header 1 — "INHERENT ABSENCE"
  Line 24377: Full-text header 2 — "INHERENT ABSENCE"
  Line 32900: RS editorial — "SET LIST TWENTY-TWO — INHERENT ABSENCE"
  Line 33239: Summary section — "Set List 22 — Inherent Absence"
  Line 36953: QR index 2 — "Set List 22 — Inherent Absence"
  Line 38252: Master index — "SET LIST 22: INHERENT ABSENCE"
  Additional prose references at lines 32901, 32904: "Set List 22 Inherent Absence"
  TOTAL: 7 structural + 2 prose = 9 confirmed appearances. Zero variants.

CANONICAL TITLE: SET LIST 22 — INHERENT ABSENCE — ALL-IN-ONE ✅

================================================================================
SECTION 2: TRACK ORDER AND COUNT — 19-TRACK CATALOG RECORD
================================================================================

STATUS: ✅ FULLY CONFIRMED — 19 TRACKS — NEW CATALOG RECORD

All 19 tracks verified against QR index 1 (line 4025) and master index (line 38252):
  1–19: All confirmed ✅ (see Block 6 of extraction for full listing)

Track count: 19 ✅ — LARGEST SET IN ENTIRE CATALOG.
  Prior record: SL18 at 14. SL22 exceeds it by 5 (36% increase).
No partial lyric notations. All 19 tracks complete. ✅

GENERATOR IMPLICATIONS:
  Fast buttons: 19-entry internal navigation needed.
  Track table: must handle 19-row layout.
  Page length: significantly longer than any prior set page.

STARS AND STRANGERS DUPLICATE NOTE (FLAG SL22-003):
  Full-text listing instance 1 shows "2. Stars and Strangers" listed twice.
  Second full-text listing (after trigger warning) shows it correctly once.
  Source PDF rendering artifact — not a track content issue. ✅
  Correct track count remains 19.

================================================================================
SECTION 3: GX VERIFICATION — FIRST NEGATIVE DELTA IN PIPELINE
================================================================================

STATUS: ⚠️ DISCREPANCY -2 — FIRST NEGATIVE DELTA — AWAITING TOM

Source stated total (both QR indexes, lines 4010 and 36953): 52
Individual ratings confirmed from QR index 1 (line 4025):
  PG tracks (1):    Stars and Strangers = 1 pt
  PG-13 tracks (11): Another Epic Poem, Tony's Song, Kill the Seed, Key To Be Free,
    Perfect, Act Fasting, Groove Back II, My Fan Fiction, Me and Tom Cruise,
    Wallflower Poop, When You're Hammered = 22 pts
  NC-17 tracks (4): Closure/Aftermath, Daylight Savings, Diddy Mockumentary Parody,
    RIP Charlie = 16 pts
  X tracks (3):    Lick My Toes Ho, Reckless Girls, Love and My Hand = 15 pts
  Total: 1+22+16+15 = 54

QR INDEX 2: IDENTICAL ratings ✅
CALCULATED TOTAL: 54
SOURCE STATED TOTAL: 52
DELTA: -2 (NEGATIVE — first in pipeline where calculated EXCEEDS source)

BC1 INVESTIGATION — RESOLUTION ANALYSIS:
  For source total of 52 to be correct from calculated 54, exactly -2 points needed.
  Available mechanisms:

  OPTION A — Two PG-13(2) tracks should be PG(1): saves 2 pts → 54-2=52 ✅
    Candidates: Stars and Strangers is the only confirmed PG.
    For two PG tracks: one additional PG-13 would need to be PG.
    Most likely PG-content candidates: Tony's Song (war/political, no profanity but
      strong content), Key To Be Free (philosophical, mild language).
    Unlikely — most PG-13 tracks have content clearly justifying PG-13.

  OPTION B — One NC-17(4) track should be PG-13(2): saves 2 pts → 54-2=52 ✅
    Candidates by downgrade probability:
    RIP Charlie (NC-17): crude humor about childhood experience, sexual reference
      with dildo — genuinely NC-17 content. LOW downgrade probability.
    Diddy Mockumentary Parody (NC-17): political satire, explicit language about
      real public figure. Borderline NC-17 vs PG-13 (satire may justify lower).
      MEDIUM downgrade probability.
    Daylight Savings (NC-17): predatory language about children at bus stops.
      NC-17 clearly justified for implied predatory content. LOW downgrade.
    Closure / Aftermath (NC-17): explicit gun violence language, murder threat.
      NC-17 justified. LOW downgrade.

  OPTION C — One X(5) track should be NC-17(4): saves 1 pt → 54-1=53 ≠ 52. FAILS.

  OPTION D — Two X(5) tracks should be NC-17(4): saves 2 pts → 54-2=52 ✅
    But all three X tracks (Lick My Toes Ho, Reckless Girls, Love and My Hand)
    contain explicit sexual content that clearly justifies X. LOW probability.

BC1 MOST PROBABLE RESOLUTION: Option B — Diddy Mockumentary Parody should be
  PG-13(2) rather than NC-17(4) in the source calculation.
  Rationale: Political satire about a public figure, while explicit in language,
  may not meet the NC-17 threshold if the source applies NC-17 only to direct
  sexual content or graphic violence. Diddy Mockumentary Parody has explicit
  language and controversial content but is primarily political parody.
  If Diddy Mockumentary Parody = PG-13(2): 1+20+12+15 = 48 ≠ 52. FAILS.

  Wait — recalculating:
  If Diddy = PG-13(2) instead of NC-17(4): removes 4, adds 2 = net -2 → 54-2 = 52 ✅

  Revised: Option B with Diddy Mockumentary Parody → PG-13 is mathematically correct.
  1×PG(1) + 12×PG-13(2) + 3×NC-17(4) + 3×X(5) = 1+24+12+15 = 52 ✅

  This is the most content-defensible single-track rating adjustment:
    Diddy Mockumentary Parody = political satire (may not require NC-17)
    vs. Closure/Aftermath, Daylight Savings, RIP Charlie (graphic violence/predatory/sexual)

FLAG GX-SL22: ⏸️ ESCALATED TO TOM
  Required from Tom: Confirm correct Total Points — 52 or 54?
  If 52: most probable adjustment = Diddy Mockumentary Parody from NC-17(4) to PG-13(2).
  Tom to confirm which track(s) should have lower ratings.

NOTE ON NEGATIVE DELTA SIGNIFICANCE:
  All prior GX discrepancies were positive (calculated < source, meaning source stated
  a higher total than what the individual ratings produce — suggesting some tracks were
  scored higher in the source's aggregate view).
  SL22's negative delta (source < calculated) is the reverse — source stated a LOWER
  total than individual ratings produce. This could reflect: (a) a source arithmetic
  error, (b) one track being scored lower in the source's aggregate than its QR rating,
  or (c) deliberate editorial decision to keep the total below a threshold.

================================================================================
SECTION 4: FOUR-WORD SUMMARY VERIFICATION
================================================================================

STATUS: ✅ ALL 19 CONFIRMED — ALL STANDARD 4-WORD FORMAT

Master index (line 38252) — all 19 summaries confirmed ✅.
Two summaries wrap in master index due to PDF line breaks — confirmed 4 words each:
  Track 2: "Roads traveled connections fading" — wrap after "connections" — 4 words ✅
  Track 12: "Fame scandal satire exposed" — wrap confirmed 4 words ✅
  Track 17: "Bathroom disaster public humiliation" — wrap confirmed 4 words ✅
  Track 19: "Drunk chaos consequences spiral" — wrap confirmed 4 words ✅

QR lowercase vs master index title case (Pattern 006). Canonical = title case. ✅

================================================================================
SECTION 5: LYRICS VERIFICATION
================================================================================

STATUS: ✅ ALL 19 TRACKS COMPLETE — ZERO PARTIAL NOTATIONS

Full-text listing confirms all 19 tracks without parenthetical notation. ✅

TONY'S SONG LYRIC ANOMALIES (FLAG SL22-006) — CONFIRMED AND PRESERVED:
  Mid-word line break "t / rying" at line ~24700: source PDF rendering artifact. ✅
  Blank fill lines "trying to_______________________": intentional source notation
    indicating a performance ellipsis or improvisation space. Preserved as found. ✅
  Both confirmed as source artifacts, not extraction errors.

LYRIC PERFORMANCE NOTES — CONFIRMED AS SOURCE-EMBEDDED:
  Track 8 (Dom - Vio): "(spoof of DOMINO by Van Morrison)" — wait, this is SL21.
    Track 8 in SL22 is Groove Back II — no embedded notes.
  Track 9 (Closure/Aftermath): Contains "that fucking cunt is gonna die" — explicit
    language consistent with NC-17. ✅
  Track 16 (Love and My Hand): Embedded authorial note in lyric:
    "(NOTE: The Premise is I keep having kids whose hands are missing...)"
    Preserved exactly as found. Source-embedded directorial note. ✅
  Track 18 (RIP Charlie): Embedded authorial note:
    "(NOTE: I end up catching mom and Charlie each putting dildos in their asses...)"
    Preserved exactly as found. Source-embedded note. ✅

================================================================================
SECTION 6: CATEGORY ASSIGNMENTS VERIFICATION
================================================================================

STATUS: ⚠️ 17/19 CONFIRMED — 2 TRACKS MISSING — PLUS SPELLING VARIANT FOUND

CONFIRMED TRACKS (17/19): All confirmed in both Book 2 instances per extraction. ✅

DIDDY MOCKUMENTARY PARODY (TRACK 12, NC-17) — CATEGORIES MISSING:
  Book 2 instance 1 (line 28240): "DIDDY MOCUMENTARY PARODY | p.517 | S22.12 | NC" — blank
  Book 2 instance 2 (line 43625): IDENTICAL — blank.
  Pattern 016 at NC-17 level (second NC-17 missing-category track — first was SL18 Wave My Hands).
  FLAG SL22-008: ⏸️ AWAITING TOM — Supply categories for Diddy Mockumentary Parody.

LOVE AND MY HAND (TRACK 16, X) — CATEGORIES MISSING:
  Book 2 instance 1 (line 29587): "LOVE AND MY HAND | p.520 | S22.16 | X" — blank
  Book 2 instance 2 (line 44972): IDENTICAL — blank.
  Pattern 016 at X level — first X-rated track with missing categories in pipeline.
  (SL21 Every Four Weeks was X but had categories: Sex.Graphic/Rated-X confirmed)
  FLAG SL22-009: ⏸️ AWAITING TOM — Supply categories for Love and My Hand.

PATTERN 016 UPDATE — RATING LEVEL EXTENSION:
  Confirmed missing-category tracks now span G through X:
    G: Pretty Gold Bracelet (SL19.1), My Garden (SL14.9), Happy Place (SL14.10),
       Expired (SL6.1)
    PG: Multiple (SL9, SL11, SL13, SL14, SL16, SL19, SL20)
    NC-17: Wave My Hands (SL18.14), Diddy Mockumentary Parody (SL22.12)
    X: Love and My Hand (SL22.16)
  Pattern 016 now confirmed at every rating level from G to X.
  The only remaining unconfirmed level is R — no R-rated tracks have appeared in pipeline.

BC1 NEW FINDING — "MOCUMENTARY" SPELLING VARIANT:
  Book 2 alphabetical index (both instances): "DIDDY MOCUMENTARY PARODY"
    — ONE 'k' missing ("MOCUMENTARY" vs "MOCKUMENTARY")
  All other sources: "DIDDY MOCKUMENTARY PARODY"
    — QR index 1 (line 4072) ✅
    — QR index 2 ✅
    — Master index summary (line 38265) ✅
    — Full-text lyric header: "(12) DIDDY MOCUMENTARY PARODY" ← also missing 'k'!
    — RS editorial: "Diddy Mockumentary Parody" ✅

  TALLY:
    "MOCKUMENTARY" (correct): QR index ×2 + master index summary + RS editorial = 4 appearances
    "MOCUMENTARY" (missing k): Book 2 alphabetical index ×2 + full-text lyric header = 3 appearances

  BC1 CANONICAL DETERMINATION:
    "MOCKUMENTARY" is the correct English word and dominant form at Tiers 2 (summary),
    3, and 4. The missing-k form appears in Tier 2 (alphabetical index) and Tier 1
    (lyric header). The master index SUMMARY uses correct "MOCKUMENTARY" even though
    the ALPHABETICAL INDEX of the same Tier 2 source uses "MOCUMENTARY."
    This is a source typo in the alphabetical index and lyric header — not a deliberate
    alternate spelling (unlike "Discartes" which is phonetically purposeful).
    CANONICAL: "Diddy Mockumentary Parody" (correct spelling) ✅ LOCKED.
    Pipeline instruction: Never use "Mocumentary" form. Index variant = source typo.

MY FAN FICTION MULTI-STRING NOTE:
  White Claude 2 correctly identified Line A as canonical and discarded orphaned
  strings at page break (Pattern 018). ✅

CATEGORY SATURATION — SL22:
  Humor/Funny: present in majority of tracks (10+/19)
  Controversy: 5+/19 tracks
  Real Life: 10+/19 tracks
  Tom Personal/Legacy: 4/19 tracks (Another Epic Poem, Groove Back II, My Fan Fiction +)
  Most varied category profile in pipeline — reflects SL22's range from G/PG introspective
    tracks to NC-17/X explicit content.

================================================================================
SECTION 7: ROLLING STONE EDITORIAL VERIFICATION
================================================================================

STATUS: ✅ CLEAN — 10/19 TRACKS — THIRTEENTH CONSECUTIVE CLEAN EDITORIAL

Source location: line 32900 — "SET LIST TWENTY-TWO — INHERENT ABSENCE" ✅
Mode A check: No SL21 or SL23 tracks present ✅
Mode B check: "When You're Hammered leaves the album on a raw, chaotic note"
  = Track 19 confirmed final ✅
Coverage: 10/19 tracks individually named (thematic editorial style)
  Named: Another Epic Poem, Stars and Strangers, Tony's Song, Kill the Seed,
    Diddy Mockumentary Parody, Lick My Toes Ho, My Fan Fiction, Perfect,
    Act Fasting, When You're Hammered

THEMATIC EDITORIAL PATTERN (updated):
  10/19 = 53% coverage — consistent with the 7/13 (~54%) ratio in prior thematic sets.
  SL13 (7/13), SL16 (7/13), SL17 (7/13), SL20 (7/13), SL22 (10/19) — all ~53-54%.
  The thematic editorial style consistently covers approximately half the tracks.

THIRTEENTH CONSECUTIVE CLEAN EDITORIAL: SL9 through SL22.
  Pattern 003 failure modes (SL6 missing, SL7 truncated) definitively limited to
  early archive phase. 13 consecutive clean editorials.

================================================================================
SECTION 8: ARTIST COMPARISON VERIFICATION — FIRST NO-NAMED-ARTIST TABLE
================================================================================

STATUS: ⚠️ A12 NEW SUBTYPE — TABLE USES GENRE DESCRIPTORS ONLY

QR index: "Lou Reed, Marilyn Manson, Nick Cave"
Comparison table (line 37683): "Spoken word, indie rock, avant-garde"

This is the first set in the pipeline where the comparison table does not contain
named artists — only genre/style descriptors.

BC1 CLASSIFICATION:
  Prior A12 instances: same-tier drift (same field, different artists or parentheticals).
  SL22: NOT a drift — the table column itself has shifted from artist names to genre
    descriptors for this row. This is a structural format change in the table for
    one set, not a naming inconsistency.
  This may reflect: (a) an intentional editorial decision (the set's style is harder
    to pin to specific artists), (b) a placeholder never filled in, or (c) a table
    entry error.

CANONICAL: QR form ("Lou Reed, Marilyn Manson, Nick Cave") for all structured fields.
  Table genre descriptors preserved in Block 12 archival notes.
  No Tom action required unless Tom wishes to add proper artist names to table.

================================================================================
SECTION 9: QG PAGE ORDERING NOTE
================================================================================

QG Page 33 of 34 = SL22. Page 34 = SL24.
SL23 appears separately in the QG (non-sequential position elsewhere).
This is confirmed QG ordering behavior — sets sorted by rating/total points,
not by set number. No pipeline action required. ✅

================================================================================
SECTION 10: CANONICAL SPELLING LOG — SL22
================================================================================

  Inherent Absence: ✅ Stable — 7 structural appearances.
  Diddy Mockumentary Parody: ✅ "Mockumentary" (with k) = canonical.
    "Mocumentary" (no k) = Book 2 alphabetical index + lyric header = source typo.
    LOCKED: always use "Mockumentary."
  Closure / Aftermath: ✅ Space-slash-space form confirmed. Stable.
  Tony's Song: ✅ Apostrophe stable.
  Key To Be Free: ✅ Capital T, B, F — stable.
  Kill the Seed: ✅ Lowercase "the" — stable.
  Groove Back II: ✅ Roman numerals confirmed.
  My Fan Fiction: ✅ Stable.
  Wallflower Poop: ✅ One word "Wallflower" — stable.
  RIP Charlie: ✅ "RIP" all caps — stable.
  When You're Hammered: ✅ Apostrophe in "You're" — stable.

================================================================================
SECTION 11: BLOCK 6 vs BLOCK 9 CONSISTENCY CHECK
================================================================================

STATUS: ✅ FULLY CONSISTENT — PATTERN 014 COMPLIANT

All 19 tracks: Block 6 categories mirror Block 9 exactly.
Missing-category tracks shown as MISSING in both blocks. ✅
No drift detected. ✅

================================================================================
SECTION 12: WHITE CLAUDE 2 EXTRACTION ASSESSMENT — SL22
================================================================================

OVERALL: ✅ HIGH QUALITY — ONE BC1 FINDING BEYOND EXTRACTION

CONFIRMED ACCURATE:
  Title (7 appearances + prose, zero variants) ✅
  19-track count (catalog record) ✅
  GX negative delta correctly identified (first in pipeline) ✅
  All 19 summaries confirmed ✅
  Zero column-swap anomalies ✅
  Pure X lead rating correctly identified (first in pipeline) ✅
  Comparison table no-named-artist correctly identified ✅
  Both missing-category tracks correctly identified ✅
  Tony's Song lyric anomalies correctly preserved ✅
  Stars and Strangers duplicate correctly identified as source artifact ✅
  My Fan Fiction multi-string correctly parsed ✅
  Editorial clean (10/19, thematic style) correctly verified ✅
  Block 6/9 mirror compliant ✅

BC1 ADDITION:
  "DIDDY MOCUMENTARY PARODY" in Book 2 alphabetical index (both instances) and
  full-text lyric header = source typo. "MOCKUMENTARY" (with k) is canonical per
  QR indexes, master index summary, and RS editorial. Not a legitimate alternate
  spelling. Lock "Mockumentary" and never use "Mocumentary" in pipeline.

BC1 GX ANALYSIS:
  Negative delta is the first in pipeline. Most probable resolution:
  Diddy Mockumentary Parody from NC-17(4) → PG-13(2) = -2 → 54-2=52 ✅
  All other rating adjustments checked and found either mathematically wrong or
  content-inconsistent.

CORRECTIONS REQUIRED: NONE

================================================================================
SECTION 13: OPEN FLAGS REGISTER — SL22
================================================================================

FLAG GX-SL22 — GX DISCREPANCY (NEGATIVE -2) — FIRST NEGATIVE DELTA  🟡
  STATUS: ⏸️ AWAITING TOM CONFIRMATION
  Stated: 52 | Calculated: 54 | Delta: -2 (first negative delta in pipeline)
  All ratings confirmed consistent between Tier 2 and Tier 3.
  BC1 most probable resolution: Diddy Mockumentary Parody = PG-13(2) not NC-17(4).
  1×PG + 12×PG-13 + 3×NC-17 + 3×X = 1+24+12+15 = 52 ✅
  Required from Tom: Confirm correct total (52 or 54) and identify which track(s)
  should have a lower rating than currently listed.

FLAG SL22-008 — DIDDY MOCKUMENTARY PARODY CATEGORIES MISSING  🟡
  STATUS: ⏸️ AWAITING TOM CONFIRMATION
  Both Book instances: NC confirmed, categories blank. Pattern 016 at NC-17 level.
  Required from Tom: Supply category list for Diddy Mockumentary Parody.
  Note: Linked to FLAG GX-SL22 — if rating drops to PG-13, categories may change.

FLAG SL22-009 — LOVE AND MY HAND CATEGORIES MISSING  🟡
  STATUS: ⏸️ AWAITING TOM CONFIRMATION
  Both Book instances: X confirmed, categories blank. Pattern 016 at X level (first).
  Required from Tom: Supply category list for Love and My Hand.

================================================================================
SECTION 14: CUMULATIVE PIPELINE STATUS UPDATE
================================================================================

PIPELINE STATUS:
  Set Lists 1–21:  ✅ VERIFIED (prior sessions)
  Set List 22:     ✅ VERIFIED — 3 Tom flags (0 blockers, 3 important)
  Set Lists 23–24: ⏳ PENDING — 2 remaining

NEW FROM SL22:
  First negative GX delta (-2). Calculated exceeds source.
  BC1 probable resolution: Diddy Mockumentary Parody = PG-13.
  First pure X lead rating.
  19-track catalog record.
  "Mockumentary" spelling locked — "Mocumentary" = source typo.
  Pattern 016 now confirmed at ALL rating levels (G through X).
  First comparison table with no named artists — genre descriptors only.
  Thirteenth consecutive clean editorial.

PARTIAL LYRICS ACTIVE (6 — unchanged):
  Expired, Either Way, Believe Me, Thick Skin, Riding a Wave, War Leonard 19

MISSING CATEGORY TRACKS ACTIVE (20 total — adding 2 from SL22):
  All prior 18 + SL22.12 (Diddy Mockumentary Parody, NC-17) + SL22.16 (Love and My Hand, X)

CUMULATIVE ACTIVE TOM ITEMS: ~44

================================================================================
END OF BLACK_CLAUDE_1_QA_REPORT_SL22_INHERENT_ABSENCE_VOL1.txt
================================================================================

NEXT TARGET: SET LIST 23 — ZIONATION
