================================================================================
IMPLEMENTATION_READINESS_SCORECARD_5_12_26.txt
CollabORhythm / Collabtunes — Implementation Simulation + Failure Prevention Phase
Generated: 5.12.26 | Mixed Claude 3 Session
PURPOSE: Honest scored assessment of every system before first production run
================================================================================

SCORES:
  READY   = confirmed, stable, safe to use now
  PARTIAL = some components confirmed, gaps exist, proceed with caution
  BLOCKED = Tom decision or external action required before proceeding
  UNSAFE  = known issues that will cause failures if used as-is

================================================================================
SECTION 1 — NAVIGATION READINESS
================================================================================

ITEM                                    | SCORE   | REASON
----------------------------------------|---------|------------------------------------------
All 34 album URLs confirmed             | READY   | Live site verified 5.12.26
Song List 1–10 URLs locked              | READY   | /song-list-N/ pattern confirmed
Set List 1–24 URLs locked               | READY   | All 24 confirmed (SL22–24 title-slug)
Songbook chapters 1–15, 17 URLs         | READY   | No drift — match labels exactly
Songbook chapters 18B–34 URLs           | PARTIAL | URLs are correct; LABELS are drifted +1
Chapter 18 duplicate                    | BLOCKED | Tom must designate canonical ch.18
Chapter 19 orphan                       | BLOCKED | Tom must decide: add to nav/hide/delete
Lady Weaver canonical URL               | BLOCKED | Tom must choose /20-35/ vs /36-35/
Revenue Streams URL                     | BLOCKED | Tom must provide correct destination
Write Club URL                          | BLOCKED | Tom must decide: new page or remove
YouTube lyric video URL                 | PARTIAL | Two slugs exist — Tom must canonicalize
SL22–24 URL format                      | PARTIAL | Title-in-slug vs number-only unresolved
Dev pages in public nav                 | UNSAFE  | HTML test1/2/3/(HTML 4) still live in nav
Switchboard Quicklinks completeness     | PARTIAL | Missing ~25 pages, misleading title
Fast Scroll body                        | PARTIAL | Page live, body not captured

NAVIGATION READINESS OVERALL: PARTIAL / BLOCKED
Minimum to reach READY: Tom answers Decisions 04, 06, 07, 08, 09, 20

================================================================================
SECTION 2 — CANON READINESS
================================================================================

ITEM                                    | SCORE   | REASON
----------------------------------------|---------|------------------------------------------
All 34 album titles                     | READY   | Confirmed from live site
Set List count = 24                     | READY   | Confirmed (updated from prior SL21)
SL1 track count = 13                    | READY   | Locked
SL1 Track 1 — Knowing the Know         | READY   | Title + LadyWeaver credit locked
SL1 Track 8 — Rain (partial)           | READY   | Locked — two stanzas only
SL1 Tracks 2–7, 9–13                   | BLOCKED | Source pull required — White Claude 2
Artist comparisons for SL1             | READY   | Dylan, Cohen, Lou Reed locked
GX scores — SL1,3,6,7,8,10            | PARTIAL | Delta:1 conflict — Tom verification needed
GX scores — all other collections       | BLOCKED | mood_settings file not yet processed
Per-track ratings (all collections)     | BLOCKED | Source pull required for most
Category tags per collection            | BLOCKED | Source pull required
Defamation risk scope                   | BLOCKED | Tom review required
Canon rules (Baseball Rule, etc.)       | READY   | Locked in CREATOR_INTERVIEW_TRANSCRIPT
Visual canon palette                    | READY   | Locked in FIXED_COLOR_README

CANON READINESS OVERALL: PARTIAL / BLOCKED
Minimum to reach READY: mood_settings file + SL1 tracks + Tom GX verification

================================================================================
SECTION 3 — TEMPLATE READINESS
================================================================================

ITEM                                    | SCORE   | REASON
----------------------------------------|---------|------------------------------------------
15-block AIO structure                  | READY   | Confirmed in Tester Two fixed-color
Fixed-color palette applied             | READY   | FIXED_COLOR files correct
Placeholder badge CSS                   | READY   | Defined in PRODUCTION_SAFE_TEMPLATE_SYSTEM
Rating badge component                  | READY   | Defined in template
Fast scroll anchor structure            | READY   | Confirmed from live pages
Back to Switchboard button              | READY   | URL confirmed
Social media bar                        | READY   | 10-platform bar from Fast Scroll
Rating gate JS framework                | PARTIAL | Logic defined; default state fix pending
Bouncer default state fix               | UNSAFE  | Still ratings[4] — must fix before any deploy
Template version locked                 | BLOCKED | Requires Tom approval of SL1 test output
Builder Three vs Tester Two clarity     | PARTIAL | Relationship unresolved (Decision 24)

TEMPLATE READINESS OVERALL: PARTIAL / BLOCKED
Minimum to reach READY: Fix bouncer (1 line) + Tom approves SL1 test + lock template

================================================================================
SECTION 4 — METADATA READINESS
================================================================================

ITEM                                    | SCORE   | REASON
----------------------------------------|---------|------------------------------------------
Page metadata schema defined            | READY   | Defined in BULK_HTML_GENERATION_STANDARDS
Rating metadata for albums 1–12         | READY   | PG/PG-13 confirmed from Quick Guide
Rating metadata for albums 13–22        | PARTIAL | Estimated; needs mood_settings confirmation
Rating metadata for SL7,8,9,17         | PARTIAL | R inferred; needs mood_settings confirmation
Rating metadata for SL23, SL24         | BLOCKED | Unknown content — source pull required
GX metadata (6 delta collections)      | PARTIAL | Conflict unresolved
Content flags per collection            | PARTIAL | DRUGS/ALCOHOL/DARK_THEMES confirmed for some
Trigger warning block content           | PARTIAL | Confirmed for SL1; source pull for others
Category tags                           | BLOCKED | Source pull required for most

METADATA READINESS OVERALL: PARTIAL
Minimum to reach READY: mood_settings file processed + source pulls complete

================================================================================
SECTION 5 — ARCHIVE / REPOSITORY READINESS
================================================================================

ITEM                                    | SCORE   | REASON
----------------------------------------|---------|------------------------------------------
Folder structure defined                | READY   | MASTER_FOLDER_STRUCTURE confirmed
Naming rules defined                    | READY   | MASTER_NAMING_STANDARD confirmed
ZIP manifest system active              | READY   | FINAL_ZIP_MANIFEST confirms all ZIPs
Prior versions preserved (not deleted)  | READY   | All VOL1/2/3 files intact
Rollback procedures defined             | READY   | ROLLBACK_AND_RECOVERY_PROCEDURES complete
Handoff package complete                | READY   | All 3 authority ZIPs built and named
Source ZIPs accessible                  | READY   | 39_ALL_IN_ONES and others confirmed
Repository physically organized         | PARTIAL | Structure defined but not yet implemented
Defamation registry filed safely        | PARTIAL | File exists; Tom review pending

ARCHIVE READINESS OVERALL: PARTIAL (mostly procedural — implement structure)

================================================================================
SECTION 6 — DEPLOYMENT READINESS
================================================================================

ITEM                                    | SCORE   | REASON
----------------------------------------|---------|------------------------------------------
Gate 1: Content safety                  | UNSAFE  | 5 live blockers still unresolved
Gate 2: Navigation integrity            | PARTIAL | 3 fails, 9 pending Tom decisions
Gate 3: Canon integrity                 | PARTIAL | 6 locked, 5 pending
Gate 4: HTML/visual system              | PARTIAL | 5 pass, 3 pending
Gate 5: File hygiene                    | PARTIAL | 3 pass, 3 fail
Front Door Bouncer fix                  | UNSAFE  | Default state = R-rated profanity still live
X-rated pages ungated                   | UNSAFE  | Live on public internet now
NC-17 pages ungated                     | UNSAFE  | Live on public internet now
Full Lyrics ungated                     | UNSAFE  | Live on public internet now
Defamation clearance                    | BLOCKED | Tom review required

DEPLOYMENT READINESS OVERALL: UNSAFE for public launch / PARTIAL for internal testing
Minimum for limited launch: Fix 5 live blockers + Tom answers critical decisions

================================================================================
SECTION 7 — GENERATOR READINESS
================================================================================

ITEM                                    | SCORE   | REASON
----------------------------------------|---------|------------------------------------------
Template model exists                   | READY   | Tester Two fixed-color
Template locked                         | BLOCKED | Needs Tom approval of SL1 test
SL1 generation data (partial)           | PARTIAL | Title, T1, T8, themes confirmed; T2–7,T9–13 missing
SL2–10 generation data                  | PARTIAL | Titles + URLs only; all content needs pull
SetList1–22 generation data             | PARTIAL | Titles + URLs + estimated ratings only
SetList23–24 generation data            | BLOCKED | Unknown content
mood_settings ratings file              | BLOCKED | Not yet uploaded/processed
Generator input field spec              | READY   | Defined in GENERATOR_INPUT_READINESS
Batch size rules                        | READY   | Defined in SAFE_DEPLOYMENT_BATCH_SIZES
QA checklist for generated pages        | READY   | Defined in BULK_HTML_GENERATION_STANDARDS
Rollback plan for generation            | READY   | ROLLBACK_AND_RECOVERY_PROCEDURES

GENERATOR READINESS OVERALL: PARTIAL / BLOCKED
Can generate: Skeletons for SL1–SL22 with SOURCE_PULL badges
Cannot generate: SL23, SL24, any page requiring confirmed per-track data

================================================================================
SCORECARD SUMMARY
================================================================================

SYSTEM                  | SCORE           | BLOCKING ITEMS
------------------------|-----------------|----------------------------
Navigation              | PARTIAL/BLOCKED | 5 Tom decisions pending
Canon                   | PARTIAL/BLOCKED | mood_settings + source pulls
Template                | PARTIAL/BLOCKED | Bouncer fix + Tom SL1 approval
Metadata                | PARTIAL         | mood_settings + source pulls
Archive/Repository      | PARTIAL         | Physical structure not yet built
Deployment              | UNSAFE/PARTIAL  | 5 live blockers + Tom decisions
Generator               | PARTIAL/BLOCKED | Template lock + source data

OVERALL PROJECT SCORE:  PARTIAL — ready for controlled internal testing only
READY FOR PUBLIC LAUNCH: NO — minimum 5 live blocker fixes + Tom decisions needed
READY FOR INTERNAL SL1 TEST: YES — can generate SL1 skeleton immediately

================================================================================
END IMPLEMENTATION_READINESS_SCORECARD_5_12_26.txt
================================================================================
